Aldo and Jeanne Scaglione Prize in Comparative Literary Studies
       
     
Shawcross Prize for Best Chapter on Milton
       
     
Poorvu Family Interdisciplinary Teaching Prize
       
     
Director's Award, MacMillan Center
       
     
Founders Prize for Best First Book Manuscript in Early Modern Studies Across All Disciplines
       
     
Isabel McCaffrey Prize for best article between 2008–2010 on Spenser and his Contemporaries
       
     
Leab Exhibition Award
       
     
Prize Teaching Fellowship for Outstanding Undergraduate Teaching
       
     
Honorable Mention, Gerald Kahan Prize
       
     
Phi Beta Kappa
       
     
Aldo and Jeanne Scaglione Prize in Comparative Literary Studies
       
     
Aldo and Jeanne Scaglione Prize in Comparative Literary Studies

2017. For The Worldmakers. Modern Langauge Association

Shawcross Prize for Best Chapter on Milton
       
     
Shawcross Prize for Best Chapter on Milton

for The Worldmakers. Milton Society of America. 2016

Poorvu Family Interdisciplinary Teaching Prize
       
     
Poorvu Family Interdisciplinary Teaching Prize

Yale University. 2016

Director's Award, MacMillan Center
       
     
Director's Award, MacMillan Center

2016. Yale University

Founders Prize for Best First Book Manuscript in Early Modern Studies Across All Disciplines
       
     
Founders Prize for Best First Book Manuscript in Early Modern Studies Across All Disciplines

2015. Sixteenth Century Society and Conference

Isabel McCaffrey Prize for best article between 2008–2010 on Spenser and his Contemporaries
       
     
Isabel McCaffrey Prize for best article between 2008–2010 on Spenser and his Contemporaries

International Spenser Society. 2010

Leab Exhibition Award
       
     
Leab Exhibition Award

for best exhibition brochure for Collecting an Empire. 2008, American Library Association.

Prize Teaching Fellowship for Outstanding Undergraduate Teaching
       
     
Prize Teaching Fellowship for Outstanding Undergraduate Teaching

Yale University, 2007

Honorable Mention, Gerald Kahan Prize
       
     
Honorable Mention, Gerald Kahan Prize

for best article on a theatre research topic. 2006, American Society for Theatre Research.

Phi Beta Kappa
       
     
Phi Beta Kappa

2001